Medical billing determines whether a healthcare facility is compensated for the services it has performed — and for most practices, it’s a persistent source of operational pain.
Claims go out with errors. Denials accumulate without follow-ups. Staff spend hours on administrative work instead of helping patients. Reimbursements that should arrive in two weeks trickle in after one, two, or sometimes three months.
The growing response to this problem is outsourcing, and it applies as much to a five-physician family medicine practice as it does to a multi-campus hospital network. Before discussing the solution, however, let’s clarify the problem.
The real issues in medical billing
Denial rates and claim errors
Denial rates in the U.S. average 5-10% of submitted claims, yet many are preventable (or reversible). Driving those numbers? Coding mistakes, missing patient information, prior authorization lapses, and timely filing violations. Each unanswered denial is revenue written off because the paperwork was wrong.
Administrative overload and staffing
Medical billing involves many tasks, including managing denials, tracking claims, and communicating with payers (and payees). These responsibilities can overwhelm staff. Employee shortages compound the problem, with nearly 80% of physicians reporting challenges in hiring and retaining qualified billing staff. When these staff are answering phones and scheduling appointments, billing gets short shrift. It’s a capacity problem inherent in the structure of small and mid-sized practices.
Regulatory complexity
Each payer has unique requirements; newer billing models like value-based care add layers of complexity. Non-compliance can lead to denials, penalties, or reimbursement delays. Annual CPT code updates, shifting Medicare rules, legislation like PA’s No Surprises Act, and payer-specific claim requirements mean that today’s accurate billing requires continuous education. An in-house generalist who handles billing along with other duties can’t realistically keep pace.
Declining reimbursements with rising overhead
Today, healthcare facility leaders say they collect less per service even though they spend more to collect payments. A minor coding error can delay payment by 30 to 90 days. When those delays compound across hundreds of claims, cash flow slows regardless of how many patients the clinic treats.
Patient collections
High-deductible health plans have shifted more financial responsibility onto patients, and collecting from individuals is harder than collecting from insurers. Practices frequently struggle to collect payments from their patients, who may not understand their bills — and, thus, don’t pay them promptly. Front-desk staff trying to explain charges while also managing appointments may not have the bandwidth to do either well.
What outsourcing medical billing delivers
Faster, cleaner claims
Outsourced billing experts submit claims daily. They apply the correct ICD-10, CPT, and HCPCS coding rules, use electronic claims to accelerate adjudication, and monitor rejections in real-time. Many practices may see their AR days shrink by 20-30% reduction within the first few months of outsourcing their billing.
Specialized expertise without the hiring costs
Third-party billing companies employ certified professionals with extensive knowledge of medical coding, payer rules, and compliance standards. These experts must stay current with changes in billing codes, Medicare policies, and insurance requirements to do their jobs effectively. A solo dermatology practice gains access to the same level of specialty-specific coding expertise that a large hospital system can afford to build in-house.
Lower operating costs
Hiring, training and retaining in-house billing staff is expensive. Add the cost of billing software, hardware, and office space, and expenses climb. Outsourcing converts fixed costs into variable costs, enabling practices to pay only for the services they use. Most vendors price on a percentage-of-collections model (typically between 4% and 9% of monthly collections), which aligns their financial incentive with yours.
Systematic denial management
Far too many practices write off denied claims because they don’t have the bandwidth to follow up. Billing partners track denials in real-time, analyze denial trends, rework and resubmit claims quickly, and conduct payer appeals where applicable. Several medical billing vendors have said that many practices recover 10-25% more on previously denied claims after implementing follow-up processes. That difference in recovery rates over a year often exceeds the cost of the outsourcing contract itself.
Scalability without the growing pains
Billing spikes can happen whenever a clinic adds providers, opens a new location, or gets hit with a patient surge during flu season. Smaller in-house teams can struggle with this influx. Billing partners have scalable services that adapt to fluctuations and can offer additional support without having to hire more staff.
Better compliance
To reduce risk and protect practices during government or payer audits, billing vendors:
- Maintain secure systems for protected health information.
- Follow the latest Medicare and payer manuals.
- Conduct internal compliance audits.
- Provide documentation for audit trails.
The real drawbacks
Outsourcing medical billing isn’t uniformly beneficial. You should consider the downsides before signing a contract.
Loss of direct (and immediate) control
When billing moves off-site, visibility often drops. If a practice is used to hands-on, daily feedback between physicians and billing staff, it takes time to find a smooth routine that’s comfortable for everyone.
Hidden fees
Some companies charge extra for onboarding or startup costs. A contract that initially looks affordable may include add-on costs for denial management, patient statements, or AR follow-up in the fine print. Read contracts carefully and ask vendors to itemize what their base fee includes and excludes.
Specialty knowledge gaps
Not every billing company understands every specialty. Generalist firms might not be the best partner for a cardiology or dental practice. Ask relevant questions because a lack of expertise can lead to the same coding errors that outsourcing is meant to prevent.
Transition disruption
Switching from in-house to outsourced billing takes time. During the handoff period, claim volume may dip. AR may temporarily worsen as the new team learns your workflows. If you opt to hire an outside vendor and have a limited cash flow, plan ahead.
How to choose the right partner
You can often determine whether a vendor improves your revenue cycle by asking a few specific questions.
- What is your specialty experience? A vendor should be able to name similar practices it has worked with and provide measurable results. General claims of expertise won’t suffice.
- What’s included in your fee? The base fee should include denial management, patient statements, eligibility verification, and AR follow-up. If any of these services are separate line items, factor them into the true cost comparison.
- What’s your approach to reporting and transparency? You should receive — at a minimum — monthly reports covering days in AR, first-pass claim acceptance rate, denial rate by payer, and net collections ratio. A vendor that’s vague about the reporting it provides should raise a red flag.
- What’s your communication structure? Find out how your billing partner will contact you if a claim pattern changes with a particular insurer, for example. Ask who you contact if you have a question. A dedicated account manager is worth their proverbial weight in gold.
- Ask about HIPAA compliance credentials. Patient data security is non-negotiable. Ask vendors to explain their data handling practices. You can also check various databases for any violations. This article is a good place to start, too.
Finally, get client references from practices of a similar size and specialty. And then call them to ask about the vendor once you’ve whittled your list down.
Medical billing outsourcing has grown substantially as a market, and the financial case for its benefits is well-supported. Large hospital networks see the value in their specialized expertise and technology at scale. Community clinics see value in offloading work that can quickly overwhelm a smaller staff. In both cases, the prerequisite for realizing that value is choosing a vendor that aligns with your specific needs and doesn’t raise any red flags.
Are you a commercial real estate investor or seeking a specific property to meet your company’s needs? We invite you to talk to the professionals at CREA United, an organization of CRE professionals from over 90 firms representing all disciplines within the CRE industry, from brokers to subcontractors, financial services to security systems, interior designers to architects, movers to IT, and more.
